Dr Alma Swan
Dr Alma Swan
In Europe, meanwhile the news was decidedly disappointing, when it finally became clear that over-cautious European politicians and bureaucrats had chosen not to act in the interests of science, and would not be pushing for Open Access.
The disappointment was all the greater given the enthusiastic way in which the research community had responded to a petition that Open Access advocates had organised earlier in the year urging the EC to act on the recommendations of its own report, and mandate all EU-funded researchers to make their papers freely available on the Internet. With the petition attracting 18,500 signatures in a matter of weeks, it was universally assumed that a mandate was inevitable. It turned out, however, that aggressive lobbying by self-serving publishers had persuaded EC officials to drop the mandate.
As project manager for the petition, Open Access advocate Dr Alma Swan was personally involved in events. When I learned that she was passing through Oxford, therefore, I tracked her down in Oxford's famous Randolph Hotel. Sitting in the (to me) somewhat incongruous surroundings of the Randolph's plush tea rooms, I asked Swan what had gone wrong, and where it leaves the Open Access movement in Europe.
Far from being fazed by developments, however, Swan was as confident as ever. "One thing that those who oppose Open Access must understand is that we are not going to give up," she assured me. "Moreover, we are going to be more tenacious than the people who oppose us."
Besides, she added, the battle isn't going to be won in the corridors of power, but in the meeting rooms and the labs of research institutions. Here, she assured me, the omens are good — as awareness continues to grow that Open Access isn't just a trendy buzz word, or even an end in itself, but the enabler for a much larger revolution; a revolution, moreover, that universities will find it increasingly difficult to resist.
Swan's quiet confidence is also hard to resist. What makes her arguments particularly compelling is that Swan is not an over-earnest ideologue, but a generous-spirited and witty woman with an infectious, and somewhat subversive, sense of fun.
Nor is she obsessed with demonising publishers. After all, she points out, in resisting Open Access they are only doing what businesses are expected to do in capitalist democracies — seeking to maximise their profits. But she adds that their hypocrisy is nevertheless depressing. While making public statements claiming to support the principle of Open Access, she says, publishers are constantly engaged in behind-the-scenes attempts to derail it.
In characteristic Swan style, when pushed to take a jibe at publishers, she ends our meeting with a humorous anecdote, remarking that one prominent member of the publisher lobby group STM has developed a sneaky habit of stealing the jokes from her presentations. With a mischievous twinkle in her eye she says, "I've told him that whenever he's in the audience when I'm presenting, it'll be a strait-laced show."
If you wish to read the interview with Alma Swan please click on the link below. I am publishing it under a Creative Commons licence, so you are free to copy and distribute it as you wish, so long as you credit me as the author, do not alter or transform the text, and do not use it for any commercial purpose.
If after reading it you feel it is well done you might like to consider making a small contribution to my PayPal account. I have in mind a figure of $8, but whatever anyone felt inspired to contribute would be fine by me.
What I would ask is that if you point anyone else to the article then you consider directing them to this post, rather than directly to the PDF file itself.